docs: updated to new auth challenge format and removed stale TOCTOU race condition note
Some checks failed
ci/woodpecker/pr/server-lint Pipeline failed
ci/woodpecker/pr/server-audit Pipeline failed
ci/woodpecker/pr/server-vet Pipeline failed
ci/woodpecker/pr/server-test Pipeline was successful
ci/woodpecker/pr/useragent-analyze Pipeline failed

This commit is contained in:
Skipper
2026-04-17 18:25:31 +02:00
parent 9ee86afc19
commit 4a8e51ef32
2 changed files with 9 additions and 25 deletions

View File

@@ -29,38 +29,23 @@ flowchart TD
A([Client connects]) --> B[Receive AuthChallengeRequest]
B --> C{pubkey in DB?}
C -- yes --> D[Read nonce\nIncrement nonce in DB]
D --> G
C -- yes --> G[Generate AuthChallenge]
C -- no --> E[Ask all UserAgents:\nClientConnectionRequest]
E --> F{First response}
F -- denied --> Z([Reject connection])
F -- approved --> F2[Cancel remaining\nUserAgent requests]
F2 --> F3[INSERT client\nnonce = 1]
F3 --> G[Send AuthChallenge\nwith nonce]
F2 --> F3[INSERT client]
F3 --> G
G --> H[Receive AuthChallengeSolution]
H --> I{Signature valid?}
I -- no --> Z
I -- yes --> J([Session started])
G --> H[Send AuthChallenge\ntimestamp + random bytes]
H --> I[Receive AuthChallengeSolution]
I --> K{Signature valid?}
K -- no --> Z
K -- yes --> J([Session started])
```
### Known Issue: Concurrent Registration Race (TOCTOU)
Two connections presenting the same previously-unknown public key can race through the approval flow simultaneously:
1. Both check the DB → neither is registered.
2. Both request approval from user agents → both receive approval.
3. Both `INSERT` the client record → the second insert silently overwrites the first, resetting the nonce.
This means the first connection's nonce is invalidated by the second, causing its challenge verification to fail. A fix requires either serialising new-client registration (e.g. an in-memory lock keyed on pubkey) or replacing the separate check + insert with an `INSERT OR IGNORE` / upsert guarded by a unique constraint on `public_key`.
### Nonce Semantics
The `program_client.nonce` column stores the **next usable nonce** — i.e. it is always one ahead of the nonce last issued in a challenge.
- **New client:** inserted with `nonce = 1`; the first challenge is issued with `nonce = 0`.
- **Existing client:** the current DB value is read and used as the challenge nonce, then immediately incremented within the same exclusive transaction, preventing replay.
Auth challenges are generated from fresh random bytes plus a timestamp. They are signed as the canonical challenge payload and are not persisted in `program_client`.
---